General HR
Which Benefits Have The Biggest Impact on a Small Budget?
Marlen Kothen
on November 13, 2026 • 8 min. reading time
Companies sign contracts, organise offerings and make sure everything is accessible to employees. That makes every benefit an investment. Even so, many of these offerings don’t boost engagement and performance the way companies hope. In this episode of “von HR für HR” (from HR for HR), Lesley talks to People & Culture expert Jessica Harenberg about which benefits are worth it even on a small budget, how to measure their success, and why leadership is what makes the difference in the end.

Why benefits alone rarely drive performance
Benefits are voluntary perks provided by the employer, and most traditional benefits only boost extrinsic motivation. In the short term, they spark enthusiasm and satisfaction. But people soon get used to them, and the offering loses its significance.
- Little impact on intrinsic motivation: Traditional benefits barely touch the motivation that comes from within people themselves.
- Little influence on recruitment and retention: Whether people join a company or stay hardly depends on traditional benefits. Their influence on performance is correspondingly small.
- Admin effort as a source of frustration: Some benefits create a lot of effort, not just for HR but for employees too. If you have to upload every single meal receipt, for example, you may not use the offering at all.
About Jessica
Jessica Harenberg has worked in People & Culture for many years and knows the operational, strategic and leadership sides of the field. Most recently, she was responsible for more than 200 people. Today, she works as a freelancer supporting several startups at once. What drives her: creating structures and conditions in which people are truly able and willing to perform.
Not all benefits are created equal
Jessica distinguishes between several types of benefits that work in very different ways:
| Category | Examples | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Traditional benefits | Meal allowance, vouchers, gym membership, company bike | Often used for financial or net pay optimisation; short-term, extrinsic effect |
| Work-shaping benefits | Flexibility (working from home, remote working), training and development | Directly shape the work itself, have an everyday impact and strengthen autonomy and self-efficacy |
| Events | Team events, culture day | Voluntary add-on that can be covered by a tax-free allowance; strengthens a sense of belonging |
| Pseudo-benefits | “Salaries paid on time”, “regular feedback meetings” | Not a nice-to-have but the standard, so not a real benefit |
Jessica sums up what makes work-shaping benefits special:
Whenever people’s sense of belonging, and above all their autonomy and self-efficacy, is strengthened, it has a completely different effect than simply having a financial advantage somewhere. That wears off quickly or is soon forgotten.
Benefits on a small budget: flexibility, training and events
According to Jessica, work-shaping benefits have the greatest impact, and they often cost little or nothing at all:
- Flexibility: Working from home, remote working and flexible working initially cost a company nothing but trust.
- Training and development: This can be offered as a budget of time, combined with a financial budget if desired.
- Events: The allowance per employee can be used for these.
Flexibility in particular can be a real competitive advantage today, deciding which people a company attracts and whether they stay. With the current wave of return-to-office mandates, this benefit is often underestimated, even though it has an impact every day and fits each person’s stage of life. A meal allowance, by contrast, is perceived very differently. According to Jessica, there’s only one lever that’s even bigger and also needs hardly any budget: good leadership.
Start with the goal, then choose the benefit
The first question should be: what do I want to achieve with this benefit?
- Financial optimisation: Salaries can’t quite keep up with those at large corporations yet, so nice-to-haves are meant to make the overall pay package more attractive. Meal allowances or vouchers are a better fit here.
- Branding: The benefits should match your employer brand.
- Recruitment and retention from the employee perspective: To keep employees satisfied and engaged, flexibility and training and development are particularly suitable, because every individual benefits from them personally.
A deliberate decision in favour of a small group can also make sense, for example a childcare allowance just for parents if family is anchored in the company’s values.
The biggest performance lever: good leadership
Asked what motivates people most, Jessica’s answer, drawn from many companies, is always the same: the number one performance lever is good leadership, whether in a startup or a large corporation. Managers shape day-to-day working life more than anyone else and therefore have the greatest impact. At the same time, motivation is individual: some people want more room to shape their work, others want more structure and a clear framework. What gives people energy, strengthens them, gets them into a state of flow and makes work enjoyable is something only the manager can find out through conversation. That’s why building relationships is a core part of leadership and the biggest lever, followed by working conditions such as working from home and flexible working. Neither requires a large budget.
The role of HR: making room for leadership
Managers need time and space to take on these responsibilities in the first place. In many companies, however, they aren’t measured by the level of trust within their team or the state of psychological safety, but by operational targets. In doing so, the company sets the direction managers follow. This is where HR can approach senior management and point out the contradiction:
We can’t expect our managers to coach and be complete enablers while at the same time only incentivising their operational results.
If the company sees that this makes people stay and want to perform better of their own accord, leadership quality should be at least as important as results.
Measuring benefits: KPIs that support your decisions
From experience, Jessica knows that clients often come to her with operational issues. A few weeks later, it frequently turns out that a structural problem or a particular mindset lies behind them. When it comes to benefits, she mainly sees two starting points:
- Startups with no budget for pay rises: They ask what can be achieved through net pay optimisation.
- Larger companies with too many benefits: The offerings have grown at random and now need to be cut back without employees feeling that something is being taken away from them.
In both cases, introducing a benefit isn’t the end of the job. Benefits should be measured, and this should be considered right from the selection stage: why do we offer them, and how will we know they’re working?
Take-up rate: Who actually uses the benefit?
- Usage intensity: How much is it really used? The classic example is the gym membership that’s taken out but barely used.
- Self-defined success: Each company has to decide for itself when a benefit is working. A take-up rate of 30 percent can be a complete success if exactly 30 percent of the workforce are parents.
Providers usually supply the analytics. Choice helps too: vouchers are popular because employees decide for themselves what to spend the money on, from clothing stores to groceries to specialist retailers. A company bike, on the other hand, may end up interesting only a few people. That’s why Jessica recommends benefits that everyone can really use.
Common benefit mistakes and how to avoid them
At the moment, Jessica almost only encounters benefits in the context of cutbacks. Companies are looking to save costs, and benefits are the first thing on the list. This shouldn’t be underestimated: even if benefits contribute little to retention, taking something away from people can have the opposite effect, whether they used it or not. Satisfaction drops. Handling this is above all a question of communication: how do I support people through the change?
Jessica has a concrete tip for countering the habituation effect: actively remind people of the benefits at least once a year by showing what’s on offer, how many people benefit, and what individuals enthusiastically say about them. This can also increase take-up.
On the topic of flexibility, Jessica gets personal: it’s also one of the reasons she became self-employed. Life is getting more stressful, and people have to juggle a lot at once, both privately and professionally. Anyone trying to manage children, pets and caring for relatives while still having to be in the office four days a week has a hard time. If, on the other hand, work can be fitted around their life, that keeps people in the company.
It doesn’t cost anything but trust. And that’s a currency that’s taking a bit of a hit right now.
Recommendations: four steps to the right benefits package
Wherever a company is on its “benefits journey”, these steps will help:
1. Take stock: Which benefits do we offer, and how are they used? 2. Define a goal for each benefit: What do we want to achieve with each individual benefit, and are we already measuring whether it’s working? 3. Identify gaps: Is there a group of employees we’re not yet catering for or who are dissatisfied, perhaps because they’ve raised it themselves? 4. Derive measures: What’s our economic situation, what can we afford, and what options are available in each case?
If you don’t have any benefits or budget for them yet, it’s still worth looking into work-shaping benefits, especially flexibility, whose impact Jessica says is still heavily underestimated.


